NSW Strata Reforms: Is Your Scheme Prepared?
NSW Strata Reforms: Is Your Scheme Prepared?
A leaking roof, an underfunded capital works fund or an undisclosed managing agent commission can quickly become more than a building management problem.
Recent changes to NSW strata laws reflect a stronger focus on three practical issues: maintaining common property, planning for future costs and improving transparency in the management of strata schemes.
For lot owners, committee members, developers and strata managers, the question is not simply whether the law has changed. It is whether the scheme is prepared when a major repair, unexpected expense or contentious decision arises.
Maintenance cannot simply be put off
An owners corporation has a statutory duty to properly maintain and keep common property in a state of good and serviceable repair.
That obligation is not new. What has changed is the level of regulatory oversight surrounding it.
Since 27 October 2025, NSW Fair Trading has had increased investigation and enforcement powers to help ensure owners corporations comply with their obligations to repair and maintain common property.
This makes prolonged inaction increasingly difficult to treat as simply an internal strata issue.
Consider a recurring waterproofing problem. A committee may initially be reluctant to proceed because the cause is uncertain or the cost of rectification is significant. But repeatedly postponing investigation can allow relatively contained water ingress to develop into damage to finishes, mould, deterioration of building elements and a much more expensive rectification project.
That does not mean every complaint requires immediate acceptance of liability or that an owners corporation must adopt the most expensive proposed solution.
The appropriate response depends on the evidence. Committees should obtain suitably qualified advice about the cause, extent and urgency of the problem and make properly documented decisions about what needs to be done.
Where defective building work may be involved, another question arises: who should ultimately bear the cost?
The owners corporation may have potential rights against a developer, builder, contractor, insurer or another party. Urgent rectification works may still be necessary, but evidence should be preserved and potential recovery rights considered before decisions are made that could affect a future claim.
Capital works planning needs to reflect the building
Maintenance obligations inevitably lead to another question: how will the scheme pay for the work?
Every strata scheme is required to prepare a 10-year capital works fund plan for anticipated major expenditure.
From 1 April 2026, 10-year capital works fund plans must be prepared using a prescribed standard form.
A capital works plan should not be treated as a document prepared simply to satisfy an administrative requirement and then left in a drawer. It should provide a realistic picture of the building's likely future expenditure.
A scheme facing ageing waterproofing, major façade works or replacement of significant building systems should be planning differently from a building without those anticipated expenses.
Underfunding does not make the future expense disappear. It can simply convert a foreseeable cost into an unexpected special levy.
At the same time, the objective is not to accumulate the largest possible fund. It is to have a rational financial plan, supported by reliable information, which reflects the likely needs of the building.
Greater transparency in strata management
The reforms also place greater emphasis on transparency in the relationship between owners corporations and strata managing agents.
Expanded disclosure requirements applying from February 2025 require strata managers to provide owners with greater information about matters including supplier relationships, commissions and other financial interests or benefits associated with their role.
The significance of these requirements is not that every commission or commercial relationship is necessarily improper.
The important point is that owners should know about those arrangements so they can make informed decisions.
For example, where a strata manager recommends an insurer, contractor or service provider and has a financial or commercial relationship connected with that recommendation, the owners corporation should have sufficient information to understand that relationship.
This makes the strata management agreement particularly important.
Before appointing or renewing an agent, owners corporations should understand the fees being charged, commission arrangements, supplier relationships, delegated authority and termination rights rather than focusing only on the headline management fee.
Good governance depends on good records
Many strata disputes become more difficult because the decision itself is only half the problem.
The other half is demonstrating how and why the decision was made.
A major repair may have been justified, but was the expert report retained? Was the expenditure properly approved? Was a conflict disclosed? Do the minutes accurately record the resolution? Can the relevant contract still be located several years later?
The reforms have strengthened the duties applying to strata committee members, reinforcing expectations that they act honestly and in good faith, exercise due care and diligence and do not improperly use their position.
Good record keeping therefore has practical value beyond administration.
Clear minutes, contracts, reports, financial records and disclosures allow an owners corporation to demonstrate that decisions were informed and properly made. Those records can also become important evidence if a disagreement later develops.
New strata schemes: getting the foundations right
The reforms also introduce greater structure around the information and financial planning provided when a new strata scheme is established.
From 1 April 2026, initial maintenance schedules must be prepared using a prescribed standard form. For multi-storey schemes, the initial maintenance schedule and initial strata levy estimates are also subject to independent review and certification requirements.
These changes address an important practical issue.
If initial levies are unrealistically low or maintenance information is incomplete, owners may purchase into a new development without an accurate picture of the building's likely future costs. The consequences may only emerge later through substantial levy increases or unexpected expenditure.
A proper handover gives the new owners corporation the information it needs to understand the building, budget realistically and respond appropriately when maintenance or defect issues arise.
What should owners corporations review now?
For most established schemes, preparing for the reforms does not require an elaborate compliance exercise.
A useful starting point is to consider:
- whether the 10-year capital works fund plan is current and reflects known or foreseeable major expenditure;
- whether significant common property repairs are being properly investigated and progressed rather than repeatedly deferred;
- whether the owners corporation understands the fees, commissions and supplier relationships associated with its strata managing agent;
- whether important decisions and conflicts are properly recorded; and
- whether contracts, reports and other important records can be readily located when required.
For schemes dealing with substantial building works or defects, these questions become particularly important. Decisions about repairs, funding and contracts can affect not only the immediate project but also the owners corporation's ability to recover losses from responsible parties.
Preparing before a dispute arises
The practical direction of the NSW strata reforms is clear: owners corporations are expected to understand their buildings, plan realistically for future expenditure, maintain common property and make decisions transparently.
For a well-managed scheme, this should not mean paperwork for its own sake. It should mean fewer surprises and better decisions.
The best time to discover that a capital works plan is inadequate, a management agreement is unclear or important maintenance has been deferred is not after the roof has failed, the contract has been signed or a substantial special levy has become unavoidable.
Addressing those issues early gives owners corporations better information, more options and a stronger position when difficult decisions need to be made.
*Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The law and its application may vary depending on the particular circumstances. You should obtain legal advice specific to your circumstances before acting or relying on the information contained in this article.
NCAT Strata Dispute Process: What to Expect
A strata dispute can move quickly from an unresolved email thread to a formal proceeding with consequences for an owners corporation, committee member, lot owner or managing agent. Understanding the NCAT strata dispute process early helps parties preserve evidence, meet procedural requirements and make informed decisions about settlement or litigation.
In New South Wales, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal, commonly called NCAT, determines a wide range of disputes arising under the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 and related legislation. It is intended to be more accessible than a court, but a strata application should not be treated casually. Jurisdiction, evidence, statutory time limits and the precise order sought can all affect the result.
What NCAT can decide in strata matters
NCAT has broad powers in strata disputes, although those powers are defined by legislation. Common applications concern repairs and maintenance of common property, by-laws, access to records, levy disputes, meeting irregularities, renovations, pets, parking, smoke drift, nuisance and the conduct of owners corporations or strata committees.
For example, a lot owner may seek an order requiring the owners corporation to repair a water leak originating in common property. An owners corporation may seek enforcement of a valid by-law against an owner whose unauthorised works affect the building. A committee dispute may turn on whether a meeting was properly convened, whether motions were validly passed, or whether records have been withheld.
The right forum depends on the substance of the claim. NCAT does not have unlimited power to award compensation or determine every dispute connected with an apartment building. Building defect claims, negligence claims, contractual disputes involving service providers, insurance issues and claims for substantial damages may require a different pathway, including proceedings in a court. The factual overlap between claims does not necessarily mean they belong in the same tribunal application.
Before filing: mediation is often required
For many strata disputes, the first formal step is mediation through NSW Fair Trading. A party generally needs to attempt mediation before making an NCAT application, unless an exception applies. The purpose is practical: parties are encouraged to identify the issue, exchange their positions and explore an outcome without the cost, delay and entrenched positions that can follow litigation.
Mediation is not a hearing and the mediator does not impose a decision. It may nevertheless be an effective forum where the dispute is capable of a practical agreement, such as a timetable for repairs, access arrangements, a revised resolution at a general meeting or an undertaking to comply with a by-law.
Mediation is less likely to resolve a matter where there is a fundamental legal disagreement, urgent safety concern, repeated non-compliance or a dispute that has already become highly personal. Even then, attending with a clear position and supporting documents can narrow the issues later placed before NCAT.
Parties should retain the mediation outcome or certificate. It may be required when filing an application, and it provides a useful record of what was proposed and what remained unresolved.
The NCAT strata dispute process step by step
Identify the legal issue and the order needed
An effective application starts with a disciplined assessment of the dispute. The question is not simply whether conduct has been unfair or frustrating. It is whether a legal obligation has been breached and whether NCAT has power to make an order that provides an effective remedy.
The orders sought should be specific. A request that an owners corporation "fix the problem" is unlikely to assist the Tribunal as much as an order requiring inspection, rectification of identified common property, provision of records by a stated date, or compliance with a particular by-law. Where works are sought, the scope, timing and access arrangements may need careful attention.
Prepare and lodge the application
The applicant files the relevant NCAT application, provides details of the parties and sets out the dispute, orders sought and supporting material. Filing fees apply and vary according to the application and the applicant's circumstances.
The application should be concise but complete. It should identify key dates, relevant correspondence, applicable by-laws or meeting resolutions, and the practical impact of the conduct complained of. Assertions without supporting material carry less weight than contemporaneous records.
Once the application is accepted, NCAT will issue a notice of hearing or directions. The applicant must ensure the correct respondents are named. In strata matters, this may be the owners corporation, a lot owner, an occupier, a strata managing agent or another party, depending on the relief sought. Naming the wrong entity can create avoidable delay.
Serve material and comply with directions
Procedural fairness is central to Tribunal proceedings. Each party must receive the material relied upon and have a reasonable opportunity to respond. NCAT may direct parties to exchange documents, statements, photographs, expert material or submissions before a hearing.
Directions must be taken seriously. Late evidence can be excluded, hearings can be adjourned, and non-compliance may weaken an otherwise sound case. Parties should organise documents chronologically, avoid duplicating large volumes of correspondence and identify the documents that actually prove the disputed facts.
In repair and water ingress disputes, useful evidence can include photographs, maintenance reports, expert opinions, invoices, building plans, strata roll extracts, minutes and correspondence about access or proposed works. In governance disputes, notices of meeting, agendas, voting records, minutes, proxies and the scheme's registered by-laws are often central.
Attend conciliation, hearing or directions proceedings
NCAT may conduct preliminary directions hearings, conciliations or a final hearing. Conciliation gives parties another opportunity to settle with the assistance of a Tribunal member. A negotiated outcome can be recorded in binding orders, which may be preferable where an ongoing neighbour or governance relationship must be preserved.
If the matter proceeds to hearing, each party presents its evidence and submissions. The hearing is less formal than a court trial, but it remains an adjudicative process. Parties should be prepared to explain what happened, refer the member to relevant documents and address why the legislation permits the order sought.
Legal representation at NCAT is not automatic. A party may need the Tribunal's permission to be represented, subject to applicable rules and circumstances. Representation can be particularly valuable where the matter involves jurisdictional issues, technical building evidence, multiple parties, contested statutory interpretation or significant commercial consequences.
Receive and comply with orders
NCAT may deliver its decision at the hearing or reserve its decision for later. Orders can require action within particular periods, dismiss an application, impose conditions, invalidate resolutions, require meetings to be held, or direct compliance with statutory obligations and by-laws.
Orders should be read closely. The practical question is not only who succeeded, but what must occur next, by whom and when. An order that requires works may need follow-up steps regarding quotes, access, approvals and funding. An order concerning a meeting may require careful preparation to prevent a further procedural challenge.
Evidence and strategy can decide the outcome
Strata disputes are often presented as personality conflicts. NCAT is more concerned with obligations, documents and evidence. A party who can show the statutory duty, the factual breach, reasonable attempts to resolve the issue and a workable remedy is usually in a stronger position than a party relying on broad allegations.
There are also strategic choices. An owner may be legally entitled to press for an order, but the cost and disruption of a contested proceeding may outweigh the benefit where a negotiated repair programme is available. Conversely, an owners corporation should not agree to a poorly defined settlement that creates open-ended obligations or conflicts with its duties to all lot owners.
Costs are another consideration. Each party generally bears their own costs at NCAT, although the Tribunal can make costs orders in limited circumstances, including where there are special circumstances. This is not a reason to approach a proceeding without preparation. The financial impact of delay, expert evidence, rectification works and impaired property use can be substantial even where legal costs are not fully recoverable.
Appeals and enforcement
A party dissatisfied with an NCAT decision may have appeal rights, but the applicable time limits and grounds matter. An internal appeal may be available in some cases, while other matters may require a different appeal pathway. Appeals are not simply an opportunity to run the same case again. They often require an identifiable error of law, procedural unfairness or a compelling basis for fresh evidence.
If a party does not comply with final orders, enforcement options may be available. The appropriate course depends on the nature of the order and the parties involved. Prompt advice is prudent before allowing non-compliance to become a more expensive secondary dispute.
A well-prepared NCAT application is not about escalating every disagreement. It is about choosing the correct process, framing a legally available remedy and protecting your position when the informal options have genuinely run their course.
When You Need an Owners Corporation Dispute Lawyer
A strata dispute rarely begins as a legal dispute. It may start with water entering a lot, a motion rejected at an annual general meeting, an unpaid levy, or a committee decision that appears to favour one group of owners over another. But where the financial exposure, building condition or governance of the scheme is at stake, early advice from an owners corporation dispute lawyer can prevent a difficult issue becoming a costly and entrenched conflict.
In NSW, strata disputes are governed principally by the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 and the Strata Schemes Development Act 2015. The applicable pathway may also involve the Home Building Act 1989, the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020, contractual rights, insurance issues and, in some cases, Supreme Court proceedings. The right strategy depends on the parties, the relief sought and the evidence available at the outset.
What an owners corporation dispute lawyer does
An owners corporation is responsible for the management, control and administration of common property. Its decisions can affect every lot owner, from the timing and cost of major works to the enforcement of by-laws and recovery of levies. That makes legal disputes more than interpersonal disagreements. They are often questions of statutory power, procedural validity, fiduciary responsibility and financial risk.
An experienced owners corporation dispute lawyer identifies the real issue before choosing a forum or commencing correspondence. For example, a dispute described as a refusal to repair may turn on whether the relevant item is common property, part of a lot, or subject to an exclusive use by-law. A challenge to a committee decision may require close examination of the meeting notice, voting eligibility, quorum, delegations and minutes. A levy dispute may be straightforward debt recovery, but it may also expose an invalid special levy resolution or an unresolved question of contribution.
The role is not limited to litigation. Sound advice may involve reviewing strata records, preserving evidence, preparing a compliant motion, advising the strata committee on its authority, issuing a carefully framed letter of demand or representing a party in mediation. Where a negotiated resolution is commercially sensible, it should protect the scheme without creating an unhelpful precedent for future disputes.
Common strata disputes in NSW
The facts and legal remedies vary considerably, but certain disputes recur across residential, mixed-use and commercial schemes.
Repair, maintenance and water ingress claims
The owners corporation has statutory duties to properly maintain and keep common property in a state of good and serviceable repair. Water ingress disputes often become difficult because the source of the damage may be uncertain. A leak can arise from a roof, balcony membrane, façade, window, plumbing line, lot renovation or a combination of causes.
The immediate priority is usually evidence. Reports, photographs, expert opinions, work orders, emails and strata records can establish what was known, when it was reported and what action was taken. Delay can increase the cost of remediation and complicate claims against builders, developers, insurers or contractors. An owners corporation should also be careful not to assume that emergency rectification resolves liability for consequential loss.
Building defects and major remedial works
Defect disputes can involve substantial special levies, competing expert evidence and multiple respondents. Depending on the age and nature of the building, legal rights may arise under statutory warranties, contractual documents or the duty of care framework under the Design and Building Practitioners Act.
There is a practical tension in these matters. Owners may reasonably want immediate repairs, while the owners corporation needs sufficient evidence to identify responsible parties and preserve a viable claim. Acting too slowly may worsen defects or affect limitation periods. Acting without a proper scope of works or technical advice can expose the scheme to unnecessary expenditure. Legal and expert advice should be coordinated from the beginning.
By-laws, renovations and use of lots
By-laws commonly regulate pets, parking, noise, short-term letting, smoking, works and the use of common property. Enforcement is not simply a matter of sending breach notices. The by-law must be valid, properly registered where required, and applicable to the conduct in question. The owners corporation must also follow the statutory process before seeking orders.
Renovation disputes can be especially contentious. The distinction between cosmetic work, minor renovation and major work affects the approvals required. A lot owner who proceeds without approval may create risks for waterproofing, fire safety, structural elements, insurance and future defect liability. Conversely, an owners corporation should not use the approval process arbitrarily or beyond its lawful power.
Levies, meetings and governance challenges
Unpaid levies affect cash flow and can prevent essential works from being undertaken. Prompt recovery action is often necessary, particularly where a scheme faces significant maintenance or insurance obligations. At the same time, the process must be accurate. Levy notices, interest, recovery costs and the underlying resolutions should be examined before proceedings are commenced.
Governance disputes may concern the validity of a general meeting, access to records, proxy voting, committee conduct, spending authority or conflicts of interest. These matters can be disruptive because they affect confidence in the administration of the scheme. Clear records and disciplined procedure are often the strongest protection.
Choosing the right forum and process
Many NSW strata disputes proceed through NSW Fair Trading mediation and, where unresolved, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal. NCAT can make a wide range of orders under strata legislation, including orders about repairs, by-laws, records, meeting outcomes and the conduct of an owners corporation or lot owner.
However, NCAT is not the answer to every dispute. Its jurisdiction is defined by statute, and the available remedies may not suit a complex building claim, urgent injunction, substantial debt or dispute involving parties outside the usual strata relationship. Proceedings in a court may be necessary where the issues involve contractual claims, negligence, declaratory relief or remedies beyond NCAT's power.
The procedural choice matters. Commencing in the wrong forum can waste time and increase costs. Equally, treating a matter as adversarial too early can make a practical resolution harder. A careful assessment should address the legal basis of the claim, the evidence required, limitation periods, the cost of expert reports, the urgency of works and the commercial objectives of the owners corporation or lot owner.
Steps to take before a dispute escalates
A strong position is usually built before an application is filed. The first step is to gather the relevant material: the strata plan, by-laws, meeting notices and minutes, correspondence, levy notices, invoices, photographs, reports, insurance documents and any expert evidence. Do not rely on recollection where the records can establish the chronology.
Next, identify who has authority to act. An individual committee member cannot necessarily bind the owners corporation. A strata managing agent's role must also be considered against the agency agreement and any delegated authority. For significant claims, an appropriately convened committee or general meeting resolution may be required.
Communication should be factual and measured. Accusations made in emails or group messages can undermine settlement prospects and, in serious cases, create separate reputational risk. Set out the issue, the action sought and a reasonable timeframe. Where technical matters are involved, avoid making definitive claims before the evidence supports them.
Finally, consider the practical outcome sought. A lot owner may need urgent works, access to records or a valid decision on a renovation request. An owners corporation may need levy recovery, compliance with a by-law or a contribution to rectification costs. The most effective legal strategy is the one that is aligned with that outcome, rather than one driven solely by frustration.
When legal advice is particularly valuable
Legal advice should be obtained early where a dispute involves major defects, substantial expenditure, a proposed special levy, repeated water ingress, allegations against committee members, threatened proceedings, statutory deadlines or a challenge to the validity of a meeting. It is also prudent where the scheme is receiving inconsistent advice from contractors, insurers, strata managers or experts.
For owners corporations, the objective is not to litigate every disagreement. It is to make defensible decisions, comply with statutory obligations and protect the collective interests of lot owners. For individual owners, it is to ensure that genuine rights are not lost through procedural delay or an incomplete understanding of the scheme's responsibilities.
Papallo Kouchoo Lawyers approaches strata disputes with that balance in mind: clear advice at the outset, close attention to the governing documents and NSW statutory framework, and decisive representation where resolution cannot be achieved. The earlier the facts, authority and desired outcome are properly defined, the more options remain available to resolve the dispute on sound terms.
Top Causes of Strata Committee Disputes in NSW
A strata committee meeting can become contentious long before anyone raises their voice. A delayed repair, an unexplained invoice or a decision made without consultation can quickly affect property values, living conditions and the confidence owners have in their scheme. The top causes of strata committee disputes usually arise from governance failures rather than a single difficult personality - although personality can certainly intensify the problem.
For NSW owners corporations, committee members and managing agents, the practical issue is not merely whether disagreement exists. It is whether decisions are being made within proper authority, recorded transparently and directed to the interests of the owners corporation as a whole. Where that discipline is absent, an operational disagreement can become a costly dispute before NSW Fair Trading or the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT).
Top causes of strata committee disputes
1. Repairs, maintenance and building defects
Repairs are one of the most persistent sources of conflict in strata schemes. Owners may disagree about whether an issue is common property, whether work is urgent, which contractor should be engaged, or whether the proposed scope and cost are reasonable. Water ingress, concrete spalling, façade issues, fire safety defects and failed waterproofing can create particular pressure because delay may cause further damage or expose the owners corporation to liability.
The difficulty is often compounded where the building is relatively new and there may be a claim against a developer, builder, insurer or consultant. One group of owners may favour immediate rectification, while another wants to preserve funds or pursue recovery first. Both concerns can be legitimate, but the committee must assess the evidence, its statutory duties and the commercial consequences of delay.
A committee should avoid treating technical building questions as matters of opinion. Clear expert reports, properly defined scopes of work, documented tender processes and advice about potential claims can reduce the scope for later allegations that a decision was uninformed or improperly motivated.
2. Levies, special levies and financial transparency
Few decisions attract closer scrutiny than requests for money. Disputes commonly arise when owners believe levies have increased without adequate explanation, capital works planning is inadequate, or a special levy has been imposed to address an expense that should have been anticipated.
Financial disagreement is not always about affordability alone. It can concern the accuracy of budgets, access to records, the allocation of expenses, payment arrangements, debt recovery and whether the committee has adequately explained why expenditure is necessary. Owners who receive short or incomplete information may assume that decisions have been made behind closed doors.
Committees should ensure budgets, motions, meeting minutes and financial records provide a coherent account of the decision. There is a practical difference between simply having records available and communicating enough information for owners to understand the purpose, urgency and likely financial impact of the proposed work.
3. Conflicts of interest and perceived favouritism
A conflict of interest does not require dishonesty. It can arise where a committee member has a personal, financial or professional connection to a contractor, managing agent, lot owner or proposed transaction. Even where the outcome is objectively sound, a failure to disclose the connection can undermine confidence in the process.
Common examples include recommending a contractor connected to a committee member, supporting works that particularly benefit one lot, or participating in a decision involving a personal dispute with another owner. Perceived favouritism may also arise where certain owners receive faster responses to maintenance requests or greater access to committee information.
Disclosure should occur early, be recorded in the minutes and be handled in accordance with the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW) and the scheme's circumstances. Depending on the issue, the appropriate response may be for the interested member not to participate in discussion or voting. The correct approach depends on the nature of the interest and the decision being considered, so a formulaic response is not always sufficient.
4. Decisions made outside committee authority
A strata committee has an important role in administering the scheme, but it does not have unrestricted power to make every decision on behalf of the owners corporation. Some decisions require approval at a general meeting, a particular form of resolution, or compliance with statutory procedures.
Disputes arise when a committee approves substantial works, enters into significant arrangements, changes access rules or deals with common property in a way that owners say should have been put to a general meeting. The issue can be especially sensitive where the decision affects the use or value of particular lots, such as parking, storage, short-term letting, renovations or exclusive use of common areas.
The safest course is to identify the source and limit of authority before a commitment is made. A decision that appears commercially sensible can still be vulnerable if the process is defective. This is particularly so where contracts have been signed, funds spent or owners have acted in reliance on the decision.
5. By-law enforcement and uneven treatment of owners
By-laws are intended to support orderly shared living, yet their enforcement is a frequent source of personal and legal conflict. Noise, pets, parking, smoking, rubbish disposal, renovations and use of balconies can all become flashpoints. The underlying issue is often not the by-law itself, but whether it is being applied consistently and fairly.
A committee that takes swift action against one owner while overlooking similar conduct by another can face allegations of selective enforcement. Conversely, a committee that fails to respond to repeated breaches may be criticised by affected residents for neglecting its responsibilities.
Effective enforcement requires evidence, a measured process and appropriate correspondence. Committees should distinguish between an isolated inconvenience and a persistent or serious breach. They should also avoid making accusatory findings without sufficient information. A considered response protects both the scheme and the rights of the lot owner concerned.
6. Communication failures and poor meeting procedure
Many strata disputes begin with a communication gap. Owners may not understand why a decision was made, whether a concern was considered, or how they can raise an objection. Committee members, meanwhile, may feel overwhelmed by constant emails, competing demands and criticism from people who are not involved in the daily administration of the scheme.
Poor meeting procedure magnifies these pressures. Inadequate agendas, unclear motions, incomplete minutes, informal voting by email and decisions made in private conversations can create uncertainty about what was actually resolved. Once trust has been lost, even routine administrative decisions may be challenged.
Committee meetings should be purposeful and properly documented. Minutes need not be lengthy, but they should accurately record resolutions, declared interests, significant reasoning where appropriate, and any authority given to spend funds or instruct contractors. A reliable paper trail is often the best protection when a decision is later questioned.
7. Personal disputes becoming governance disputes
Strata living brings together people with different financial interests, lifestyles and expectations. A disagreement between neighbours can become a committee dispute when it affects voting, by-law enforcement, repair decisions or access to information. In smaller schemes, where a small number of owners hold committee positions, personal conflict can effectively stall the administration of the entire building.
It is tempting to treat these disputes as merely interpersonal. That approach can be costly. Personal allegations, hostile correspondence and informal campaigns to remove committee members can distract from the legal and practical issues that require resolution. The committee must continue to act for the owners corporation, rather than for individual alliances or grievances.
Where relationships have deteriorated, an independent legal assessment can help separate the legal merits from the emotion of the dispute. It may identify a procedural solution, a properly framed motion, an appropriate records request or a pathway to mediation before positions become entrenched.
Managing a dispute before it escalates
Early action does not mean avoiding difficult decisions. It means making them with proper authority, evidence and process. Committee members should obtain advice before committing to high-value works, responding to serious defect allegations, enforcing a contentious by-law or taking steps that may materially affect an owner's rights.
Owners should also be careful about the remedy they seek. A request for records, a challenge to a meeting process, a concern about an unauthorised expenditure and an application for orders each require different evidence and procedural steps. In some matters, mediation may offer a practical outcome; in others, urgent legal advice is required to preserve rights or prevent further loss.
For committees facing entrenched conflict, the objective should be to restore lawful decision-making, not simply to win the next vote. Clear advice at the point where a disagreement first becomes a governance issue can protect the scheme's funds, reduce personal exposure and give owners a defensible path forward.
When You Need an Owners Corporation Dispute Lawyer
A strata dispute rarely begins as a legal dispute. It may start with water entering a lot, a motion rejected at an annual general meeting, an unpaid levy, or a committee decision that appears to favour one group of owners over another. But where the financial exposure, building condition or governance of the scheme is at stake, early advice from an owners corporation dispute lawyer can prevent a difficult issue becoming a costly and entrenched conflict.
In NSW, strata disputes are governed principally by the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 and the Strata Schemes Development Act 2015. The applicable pathway may also involve the Home Building Act 1989, the Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020, contractual rights, insurance issues and, in some cases, Supreme Court proceedings. The right strategy depends on the parties, the relief sought and the evidence available at the outset.
What an owners corporation dispute lawyer does
An owners corporation is responsible for the management, control and administration of common property. Its decisions can affect every lot owner, from the timing and cost of major works to the enforcement of by-laws and recovery of levies. That makes legal disputes more than interpersonal disagreements. They are often questions of statutory power, procedural validity, fiduciary responsibility and financial risk.
An experienced owners corporation dispute lawyer identifies the real issue before choosing a forum or commencing correspondence. For example, a dispute described as a refusal to repair may turn on whether the relevant item is common property, part of a lot, or subject to an exclusive use by-law. A challenge to a committee decision may require close examination of the meeting notice, voting eligibility, quorum, delegations and minutes. A levy dispute may be straightforward debt recovery, but it may also expose an invalid special levy resolution or an unresolved question of contribution.
The role is not limited to litigation. Sound advice may involve reviewing strata records, preserving evidence, preparing a compliant motion, advising the strata committee on its authority, issuing a carefully framed letter of demand or representing a party in mediation. Where a negotiated resolution is commercially sensible, it should protect the scheme without creating an unhelpful precedent for future disputes.
Common strata disputes in NSW
The facts and legal remedies vary considerably, but certain disputes recur across residential, mixed-use and commercial schemes.
Repair, maintenance and water ingress claims
The owners corporation has statutory duties to properly maintain and keep common property in a state of good and serviceable repair. Water ingress disputes often become difficult because the source of the damage may be uncertain. A leak can arise from a roof, balcony membrane, façade, window, plumbing line, lot renovation or a combination of causes.
The immediate priority is usually evidence. Reports, photographs, expert opinions, work orders, emails and strata records can establish what was known, when it was reported and what action was taken. Delay can increase the cost of remediation and complicate claims against builders, developers, insurers or contractors. An owners corporation should also be careful not to assume that emergency rectification resolves liability for consequential loss.
Building defects and major remedial works
Defect disputes can involve substantial special levies, competing expert evidence and multiple respondents. Depending on the age and nature of the building, legal rights may arise under statutory warranties, contractual documents or the duty of care framework under the Design and Building Practitioners Act.
There is a practical tension in these matters. Owners may reasonably want immediate repairs, while the owners corporation needs sufficient evidence to identify responsible parties and preserve a viable claim. Acting too slowly may worsen defects or affect limitation periods. Acting without a proper scope of works or technical advice can expose the scheme to unnecessary expenditure. Legal and expert advice should be coordinated from the beginning.
By-laws, renovations and use of lots
By-laws commonly regulate pets, parking, noise, short-term letting, smoking, works and the use of common property. Enforcement is not simply a matter of sending breach notices. The by-law must be valid, properly registered where required, and applicable to the conduct in question. The owners corporation must also follow the statutory process before seeking orders.
Renovation disputes can be especially contentious. The distinction between cosmetic work, minor renovation and major work affects the approvals required. A lot owner who proceeds without approval may create risks for waterproofing, fire safety, structural elements, insurance and future defect liability. Conversely, an owners corporation should not use the approval process arbitrarily or beyond its lawful power.
Levies, meetings and governance challenges
Unpaid levies affect cash flow and can prevent essential works from being undertaken. Prompt recovery action is often necessary, particularly where a scheme faces significant maintenance or insurance obligations. At the same time, the process must be accurate. Levy notices, interest, recovery costs and the underlying resolutions should be examined before proceedings are commenced.
Governance disputes may concern the validity of a general meeting, access to records, proxy voting, committee conduct, spending authority or conflicts of interest. These matters can be disruptive because they affect confidence in the administration of the scheme. Clear records and disciplined procedure are often the strongest protection.
Choosing the right forum and process
Many NSW strata disputes proceed through NSW Fair Trading mediation and, where unresolved, the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal. NCAT can make a wide range of orders under strata legislation, including orders about repairs, by-laws, records, meeting outcomes and the conduct of an owners corporation or lot owner.
However, NCAT is not the answer to every dispute. Its jurisdiction is defined by statute, and the available remedies may not suit a complex building claim, urgent injunction, substantial debt or dispute involving parties outside the usual strata relationship. Proceedings in a court may be necessary where the issues involve contractual claims, negligence, declaratory relief or remedies beyond NCAT's power.
The procedural choice matters. Commencing in the wrong forum can waste time and increase costs. Equally, treating a matter as adversarial too early can make a practical resolution harder. A careful assessment should address the legal basis of the claim, the evidence required, limitation periods, the cost of expert reports, the urgency of works and the commercial objectives of the owners corporation or lot owner.
Steps to take before a dispute escalates
A strong position is usually built before an application is filed. The first step is to gather the relevant material: the strata plan, by-laws, meeting notices and minutes, correspondence, levy notices, invoices, photographs, reports, insurance documents and any expert evidence. Do not rely on recollection where the records can establish the chronology.
Next, identify who has authority to act. An individual committee member cannot necessarily bind the owners corporation. A strata managing agent's role must also be considered against the agency agreement and any delegated authority. For significant claims, an appropriately convened committee or general meeting resolution may be required.
Communication should be factual and measured. Accusations made in emails or group messages can undermine settlement prospects and, in serious cases, create separate reputational risk. Set out the issue, the action sought and a reasonable timeframe. Where technical matters are involved, avoid making definitive claims before the evidence supports them.
Finally, consider the practical outcome sought. A lot owner may need urgent works, access to records or a valid decision on a renovation request. An owners corporation may need levy recovery, compliance with a by-law or a contribution to rectification costs. The most effective legal strategy is the one that is aligned with that outcome, rather than one driven solely by frustration.
When legal advice is particularly valuable
Legal advice should be obtained early where a dispute involves major defects, substantial expenditure, a proposed special levy, repeated water ingress, allegations against committee members, threatened proceedings, statutory deadlines or a challenge to the validity of a meeting. It is also prudent where the scheme is receiving inconsistent advice from contractors, insurers, strata managers or experts.
For owners corporations, the objective is not to litigate every disagreement. It is to make defensible decisions, comply with statutory obligations and protect the collective interests of lot owners. For individual owners, it is to ensure that genuine rights are not lost through procedural delay or an incomplete understanding of the scheme's responsibilities.
Papallo Kouchoo Lawyers approaches strata disputes with that balance in mind: clear advice at the outset, close attention to the governing documents and NSW statutory framework, and decisive representation where resolution cannot be achieved. The earlier the facts, authority and desired outcome are properly defined, the more options remain available to resolve the dispute on sound terms.
Transfer of Building & Strata Claims between NCAT and Courts
Clients will need to be extremely careful as to where a building and construction claim is commenced.
NCAT (or the Tribunal) has primary jurisdiction in relation to many homebuilding matters.
At times, a client may commence a homebuilding claim in a court and then be ‘pulled’ into NCAT at great cost and expense.
We have had cases where there were multiple proceedings on foot (one in NCAT for example and one in a court, e.g. the Supreme Court).
Careful thought needs to be given as to whether or not a matter needs to be transferred from a court to NCAT or in more limited cases, vice versa. Sometimes respective questions in relation to one matter can stay in two jurisdictions if the court and NCAT have different jurisdictions. A transfer application can also be made when either a court or NCAT has the full jurisdiction to hear all matter related questions.
This is where things can at times end in disaster.
For example, when commencing proceedings, litigants need to be very careful to ensure that there are no claims commenced (by them or the other side) in another jurisdiction and, in the least, that different questions are before those forums with each having a separate and distinct jurisdiction to hear the separate questions before them.
In one case, The Owners – Strata Plan No 47035 v Athens [2025] NSWSC 1588, the parties had previously transferred the matter into the Supreme Court (from the Local Court), and had spent about five years there (since 2020). During the final hearing however, Justice Elkaim noted that the Supreme Court may not have had the requisite jurisdiction, because a similar case, on similar issues, was commenced in NCAT before the Supreme Court matter commenced. Justice Elkaim saw no other choice but to transfer the matter to NCAT.
It is in cases like this, that the enormous cost and time of the matter, costs which have been already spent in one jurisdiction, may all essentially be for nothing.
At Papallo Kouchoo Lawyers, we do our utmost to ensure that we do our detailed ‘due diligence’ before we commence proceedings, ensuring to uphold your rights to the maximum extent of the law.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us for an obligation free professional consultation.
Lot Property vs Common Property in NSW Strata (and Why It Matters)
If you live in a strata scheme in New South Wales, one of the most important things to understand is what you own as a lot owner, and what belongs to the owners corporation. This is not just a technical issue. It determines who must pay for repairs, who must organise them, who can approve renovations, and what happens when something goes wrong such as leaks, cracked tiles, window damage or balcony defects.
The basic rule is straightforward: common property is the responsibility of the owners corporation, and lot property is the responsibility of the lot owner. The difficulty is that the line between the two is not always obvious. The strata plan is the starting point, but it does not show every detail. When boundaries are unclear, the answer can also depend on the strata legislation, relevant case law and any by-laws made by the scheme.
What is Common Property?
Common property is generally everything in the strata scheme that is not part of an individual lot. The NSW Strata Schemes Development Act defines common property as any part of the parcel not comprised in a lot, including common infrastructure that is not part of a lot.
In practical terms, common property usually includes the building’s structure and the parts that support or protect the scheme as a whole. That often means the external walls, roof, slabs, structural floors and ceilings, windows and balcony doors, and key services such as shared plumbing, electrical wiring, fire safety systems and waterproofing membranes. Even if some of these items are located inside your apartment, they may still be common property if they form part of the building’s structure or shared systems.
The owners corporation has the legal duty to maintain and repair common property, and it uses levies paid by owners to do this work.
What is Lot Property?
Lot property is the part of the building you own privately. Generally, it includes the internal space of your apartment or townhouse and the fixtures and finishes within it, unless the strata plan or by-laws say otherwise.
For most strata schemes registered after 1 July 1974, a practical guide used across NSW is that structures shown on the strata plan with a solid thick line are common property, while structures shown on a thin line are usually lot property. Internal walls that are not shown on the strata plan are usually lot property.
The Key Exceptions You Must Know
Not every scheme follows the same boundary rules. A major exception is that the general post-1974 position does not apply to strata plans registered before July 1974, where boundaries may be defined differently, sometimes using a “centre line” approach.
Also, notations on the strata plan can change the usual assumptions, and approved renovations or special by-laws can shift responsibility for particular items over time. NSW even provides a “common property memorandum” that schemes can adopt to help clarify responsibility, especially where disputes frequently arise.
Because of these variations, there is no single answer that fits every building. When in doubt, it is wise to seek expert advice based on your strata plan and your scheme’s history.
Why This Matters to You as a Lot Owner
This matters because it affects money, repairs, approvals and risk.
If something is common property, the owners corporation must arrange and pay for repairs. If something is lot property, the lot owner pays. Getting this wrong can mean unexpected bills or delays while responsibility is argued.
It also matters for renovations. Lot owners generally cannot change common property without proper owners corporation approval, and in many cases, a by-law is required where renovations affect waterproofing, structure, external appearance or shared services.
Finally, it matters for insurance and liability. Building insurance usually relates to the building and common property, while lot owners insure their contents and improvements. When boundaries are unclear, claims and repairs can be delayed.
A Simple Takeaway
In NSW strata, you usually own the internal finishes and fixtures within your lot. The owners corporation usually owns the structural parts of the building and the shared systems, even if they run through your unit. The strata plan is the starting point, but legislation, case law, notations and by-laws can change the result. If you are unsure, it is better to check early – because the financial and practical consequences of getting it wrong can be significant.
If you need assistance determining whether an item is lot property or common property, please feel free to contact us for a professional, obligation-free consultation.
.
Why the Strata Building Bond Matters for Owners Corporations
The Strata Building Bond and Inspections Scheme, commonly referred to as the SBBIS, was introduced by the NSW Government as part of a broader effort to improve confidence and accountability in the construction industry. For Owners Corporations of newly completed residential apartment buildings, this scheme provides an important layer of financial protection, but only if the process is properly understood and actively engaged with.
Under the SBBIS, developers of certain strata residential apartment buildings are required to lodge a building bond with the Secretary of the NSW Government before an occupation certificate is issued. The bond is currently calculated at two per cent of the total contract price for all contracts for the building work, noting that a planned increase to three per cent has been deferred until 1 July 2026. The bond applies not only to residential components but also to common property, car parks, and mixed-use areas such as retail or commercial spaces within the same building.
The purpose of the building bond is to ensure that funds are available to rectify defects in the building if the developer fails to do so. If no defects are identified through the inspection process, or if all identified defects are properly rectified, the bond is returned to the developer. Importantly, the bond is held by the NSW Government, not by the Owners Corporation, and it can only be accessed through the formal SBBIS process.
A central feature of the SBBIS is the requirement for independent inspections of the building. An independent and appropriately qualified building inspector is appointed to carry out an interim inspection between 15 and 18 months after the building is completed, followed by a final inspection between 21 and 24 months after completion. These inspections focus on defects affecting common property. The inspector produces reports identifying any defects and, at the final inspection, assessing whether those defects have been adequately rectified.
While the inspection process is regulated, the role of the Owners Corporation is critical. The effectiveness of the scheme depends heavily on whether defects are properly identified, documented, and addressed during the inspection period. If defects are missed, poorly described, or not challenged when necessary, the opportunity to rely on the building bond may be lost. For this reason, Owners Corporations should take an active role in the process, carefully review inspection reports, raise concerns about additional defects, and ensure that known issues are brought to the inspector’s attention.
If defects identified through the SBBIS process are not rectified by the developer, the bond may be used by the Secretary to fund rectification works. However, the bond is limited in value and may not be sufficient to address all defects. This makes early identification and strategic use of the SBBIS process particularly important. Owners Corporations that are passive or disengaged risk finding themselves responsible for rectification costs once the bond is released.
Given the technical and legal complexity of building defect issues, many Owners Corporations benefit from obtaining independent building and legal advice during the SBBIS process. Expert input can assist in identifying defects that may not be obvious, ensuring that inspection reports accurately reflect the condition of the building, and protecting the Owners Corporation’s position if disputes arise. Early advice is especially important, as missed deadlines or procedural missteps can significantly limit the ability to recover funds under the bond.
Ultimately, the Strata Building Bond and Inspections Scheme is a valuable consumer protection mechanism, but it is not automatic. Owners Corporations that understand the process, monitor key timeframes, and actively participate in inspections are far better placed to protect their building and their financial interests. Being informed and proactive from the outset can make the difference between recovering funds to address defects and being left to bear those costs long after the developer has exited the project.
If you’re concerned or have any questions about your defect claim or building bond matter, reach out to us for a free professional consultation.
.
.





